A grant-funded project audit is an independent check of whether the funds were spent in line with the budget and the terms of the grant agreement. The auditor compares the project financial report with the accounting records and documents and checks procurement, payroll, currency conversions and cash balances. Preparation should start in the first month of the project, not after it ends.
The grant agreement or the donor’s terms of reference (ToR) define what exactly must be checked, under which standard and by what date the auditor’s report is due. In Ukraine, auditors work under the International Standards on Auditing (Article 13 of the Law of Ukraine No. 2258-VIII “On Audit of Financial Statements and Auditing Activity”).
Which type of review the donor requires
A grant agreement may provide for one of two reviews, and the choice determines which document the donor receives. An audit of the project financial report ends with an auditor’s report that contains an opinion. An expenditure verification under agreed-upon procedures ends with a report of factual findings without an audit opinion, and the client and the donor draw the conclusions.
An audit of the project financial report is performed under the International Standards on Auditing (ISA), in particular ISA 800 and ISA 805 (Revised). ISA 800 covers financial reports prepared under special rules, such as the donor’s rules. ISA 805 applies when a single statement is audited, for example a statement of the project’s receipts and expenditures.
An expenditure verification is performed under International Standard on Related Services (ISRS) 4400 (Revised) “Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements”. Donors’ terms of reference cite it as ISRS 4400.
| Criterion | Audit of the project financial report | Expenditure verification under agreed-upon procedures |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | ISA, in particular ISA 800 and ISA 805 (Revised) | ISRS 4400 (Revised) |
| Subject | The project financial report as a whole | Costs and other data defined in the list of procedures |
| Who sets the scope of procedures | The auditor, based on risk assessment and materiality | The auditor and the client when they agree the list of procedures; the donor may set it in the terms of reference |
| Result | An auditor’s report with an opinion on whether the report is prepared in accordance with the donor’s rules in all material respects | An agreed-upon procedures report with factual findings, without an audit opinion and without providing assurance; the client and the donor draw the conclusions |
In an auditor’s report under ISA 800 (Revised), the auditor states in a separate paragraph that the project report is prepared under the donor’s rules and may not be suitable for another purpose. This is not a modification of the opinion but a required element of the report under this standard.
If the donor or the charter requires a financial statement audit of the organization as a whole, this is a separate engagement. We have explained how an audit of general-purpose financial statements differs from an audit of project financial statements.
What the auditor checks in a grant-funded project
The list of procedures depends on the agreement. If the donor reimburses actual costs, each cost must be real, included in the budget, incurred in the period set by the agreement, recorded in the accounts and supported by documents. For any part of the budget funded through fixed amounts or rates, the agreement sets separate conditions. The auditor checks, in particular, the following areas:
- Cost eligibility. For the selected transactions, the auditor compares the accounting entry with the contract, the acceptance certificate or delivery note, the payment document and the bank statement. The date when the service was provided or the goods were delivered must fall within the project period, unless the agreement makes an exception (for example, for the final audit), and the cost must match a budget line.
- Budget execution. Actual costs are compared with the approved budget line by line. If a line is overspent beyond the variance that the agreement allows and without the donor’s written consent, the costs may be disallowed.
- Procurement. The auditor checks whether the supplier was selected in line with the grant agreement and the organization’s procurement policy, how many quotations were received, whether there is a record of the selection and whether there was a conflict of interest.
- Payroll. The auditor reviews employment and civil-law contracts, internal orders, timesheets and payroll sheets and checks that applicable taxes and contributions were paid. If an employee works on several projects, the split of their salary is supported by the documents that the donor requires, such as timesheets.
- Currency conversions. If the report to the donor is prepared in the grant currency, the amounts from the accounting records are converted. The auditor checks whether they were converted using the method set in the agreement and whether the method was applied consistently.
- Equipment and other assets. The auditor checks whether the items bought with grant funds were recorded in the accounts, whether there are inventory records and whether the assets are used in the project.
- Receipts and balances. The auditor reconciles the tranches received, the interest earned on the cash balance (if the agreement requires it to be reported) and the closing balance with the bank statements.
- Double funding. The auditor checks that the same cost, or part of it, has not been reimbursed by two donors. If the agreement requires co-financing, the organization’s own contribution is supported under the terms of the agreement, depending on the type of contribution.
In parallel, the auditor assesses internal control: who approves costs, whether duties are separated and how often the budget is reconciled. The auditor communicates significant deficiencies in internal control identified during the audit in writing and on a timely basis to the organization’s governing body and management. ISA 265 requires this. After the audit, we also provide a management letter that sets out the deficiencies found and our recommendations.
Which documents to prepare for a grant audit
During planning, the auditor sends a list of the documents needed. It is worth preparing the following:
- the grant agreement with its annexes and amendments, the approved budget and correspondence with the donor on changes to the budget and deadlines;
- the donor’s rules on financial reporting, procurement and cost eligibility, and the terms of reference for the audit;
- the project financial reports for the period under review and the interim reports already submitted to the donor;
- the project’s accounting data: a trial balance with project-level detail, bank statements and cash documents;
- contracts, source documents (acceptance certificates, delivery notes, expense reports), invoices and payment documents;
- procurement files: requests for quotations and the quotations received, supplier selection records and declarations of no conflict of interest;
- HR and payroll documents: contracts, internal orders, timesheets, payroll sheets and proof of payment of taxes and contributions;
- asset records: inventory lists and commissioning or asset transfer certificates;
- reports from previous audits and management letters, if any, with notes on what has already been corrected.
Before the audit, reconcile three sources: the project financial report, the accounting records and the bank statements. Unexplained differences between them may lead to additional requests, so it is better to prepare the explanations in advance.
Common audit findings and how to prevent them
If the donor declares a cost ineligible, it may request a refund. The table shows findings that may come up in a grant-funded project and ways to prevent them.
| Finding | How to prevent it |
|---|---|
| A cost was incurred outside the project period without an exception allowed by the agreement | Check the date when the service was provided or the goods were delivered, not only the payment date |
| A budget line was overspent without the donor’s approval | Compare actual costs with the budget every month and get written consent before overspending |
| A purchase was made without the required number of quotations | Keep a procurement file for every purchase for which the donor’s rules require a comparison of quotations |
| Salary was charged to the grant without documents showing how working time was split | Keep monthly timesheets by project signed by the employee and the manager, unless the donor requires a different form |
| The exchange rate does not follow the agreement | Convert amounts for the donor report using the method in the agreement, apply it consistently and explain differences from the accounting records in a reconciliation |
| A cost is not supported by a source document | Check the documentary basis for each payment, follow up on acceptance certificates or delivery notes for advance payments and keep the documents separately for the project |
| The financial report does not match the accounting records | Reconcile the report with the accounting records and the bank before submitting it to the donor |
The donor decides on ineligible amounts under the terms of the agreement, so provide documents and explanations to the auditor before the report is issued. We have collected the general rules to follow throughout the project in our article on the key rules of grant project audits.
How to prepare for a grant-funded project audit
If the reporting period ends on December 31, we recommend signing the agreement with the auditor before the end of December. This allows you to agree the timing of the work and the report date in advance, taking the donor’s deadline into account. We recommend splitting the rest of the preparation into six stages:
- At the start of the project. Set up separate sub-accounts or analytical codes for the project, approve a procurement policy and a timesheet form and include an audit line in the budget. We have covered grant accounting in a separate article.
- Every month. Compare actual costs with the budget, file source documents by budget line and close the timesheets.
- Two to three months before the end of the reporting period. Re-read the agreement’s audit requirements: the type of review, the standard, the report deadline and the requirements for the auditor. Request proposals from auditors and, if the donor approves the candidate, allow time for that too.
- After the period closes. Close the books, prepare the project financial report, reconcile it with the accounting records and the bank and collect the documents on the auditor’s list.
- During the audit. Appoint a responsible person who provides documents and explanations quickly, and agree a schedule of requests with the auditor.
- After the report. Draw up a plan of corrections based on the management letter, so that the next audit does not repeat the same findings.
Before signing the agreement, check the firm in the Register of Auditors and Audit Entities: a firm may provide audit services only after it is registered there (Article 20 of Law No. 2258-VIII). The auditor must also be independent and must not take part in the organization’s management decisions, either in the reporting period under audit or while providing audit services (Article 10 of the same law). We have collected other criteria in our article on how to choose an external auditor for a non-profit organization.
UHY Prostir carries out audits of non-profit organizations and grant-funded projects, including international technical assistance projects, and expenditure verifications under procedures agreed with the client or the donor; if needed, we prepare reports in Ukrainian and English. To determine the type of review your donor requires and plan the audit before the end of the year, contact our team.




