Non-profit organizations buying various services from non-residents
When we audit the general-purpose and/or project financial statements of non-profit organizations, we very often see transactions in which these organizations buy various services (consulting, legal, translation, advertising, seminar organization, etc.) from non-residents (and not only from legal entities but also from individuals).
Under clauses 186.2 and 186.3 of the Tax Code of Ukraine (the “Tax Code”), the place of supply of such services is the territory of Ukraine. So these services are subject to VAT under subparagraph “b” of clause 185.1 and clause 208.2 of the Tax Code. Accountants of non-profit organizations almost always find this a surprise. As a rule, they all believe that if a non-profit organization is not a VAT payer, it cannot have any transactions subject to VAT at all. After reviewing the audit results, accountants of non-profit organizations ask quite reasonable questions: “How can we fix this?”, “What fines do we have to pay in addition to the VAT itself?”, “How do we file an amended return (the form used to correct an earlier filing) with the State Fiscal Service (SFS)?”
How to file an amended return with the tax authority and pay the VAT with fines?
At first sight, there is nothing complicated about it: you just need to file the relevant document with the tax authority and pay the VAT together with fines and penalty interest. In reality, however, things are far from simple for a non-profit organization (both with filing documents with the local tax office and with calculating the possible fines that a non-profit organization must pay for late reporting and late payment of tax liabilities to the budget).
For late payment of VAT liabilities to the budget, you must follow clause 126.1 of the Tax Code (Article 126 “Violation of the Rules for Paying (Transferring) Taxes”). This is the only article in the Tax Code that sets out the consequences (sanctions) for a legal entity that pays its tax liabilities late (clauses 126.2 and 126.3 of this article cannot apply in our case). However, our situation is more complicated because the non-profit organization is not a VAT payer (and, in turn, did not file VAT returns for previous periods). In our view, a literal reading of clause 126.1 of the Tax Code suggests that this rule can only apply to late payment of an “agreed amount of monetary obligation”, that is, the amount of tax liability that the non-profit organization declared in a VAT return filed with the SFS (see also clause 54.1 of the Tax Code) or in another reporting document (see below). Since the non-profit organization did not declare its VAT liabilities for the previous tax period, we can hardly speak of an “agreed amount of monetary obligation”.
In our case, we can rather speak of the possible application of the third paragraph of clause 50.1 of the Tax Code: a fine of 5% of the amount by which the VAT liability for previous tax periods was understated (the months in which the NGO carried out transactions subject to VAT). On the other hand, from a technical point of view, this will hardly be possible. The reason is that the NGO’s accountant would need to file amended returns for the relevant previous tax periods, and of course the NGO’s accountant never filed the original returns with the SFS.
At the same time, the non-profit organization (as a non-VAT payer) could not have filed either a return or an amended return. Under clause 208.4 of the Tax Code, such an organization had to file a special reporting document: “Calculation of tax liabilities accrued by a recipient of services not registered as a VAT payer for services supplied by non-residents, including their permanent establishments not registered as taxpayers, in the customs territory of Ukraine” (see Order of the Ministry of Finance No. 159/28289 of January 28, 2016). And the worst part is that the template of this document does not even have fields such as “amended calculation”, “reporting period being amended”, etc.
In view of all the above, we recommend the following in this situation:
- Fill in and file with the SFS office at the NGO’s place of registration the “Calculations of tax liabilities accrued by a recipient of services not registered as a VAT payer for services supplied by non-residents, including their permanent establishments not registered as taxpayers, in the customs territory of Ukraine” for the months in which the non-profit organization had taxable transactions, showing the amount of tax liabilities for the relevant reporting periods.
- Then wait for the tax assessment notices (podatkove povidomlennia-rishennia) that the SFS may send to the non-profit organization by mail, imposing fines for filing these documents late for the relevant tax periods (UAH 170 or UAH 1,020 under clause 120.1 of the Tax Code). As one possible (though unlikely) option, the SFS may send the non-profit organization a tax assessment notice requiring it to pay a 5% fine under clause 50.1 of the Tax Code.
- If you receive the tax assessment notices mentioned in the previous point, pay the fines stated in them within the deadlines set by law.
However, you can start all this only once you are fully sure that the transactions the non-profit organization carried out with non-residents can really be classified under the Tax Code as transactions with a “place of supply in the territory of Ukraine”. The Tax Code contains a large number of different reservations, exceptions, conditions, etc., so it is not always easy to classify these transactions correctly. Our experts will be glad to assist you in determining whether your organization has such transactions and will then offer you a clear step-by-step plan to correct the situation.




