As promised in our previous article, we continue to introduce you to the activities of non-governmental organizations (NGOs), the specifics of their accounting and their relations with other businesses in Ukraine. Today we will talk about how NGOs work with sole proprietors registered in Ukraine (FOP). What should an NGO pay attention to when it orders a service or goods from an FOP? What risks can arise in accounting and tax accounting when an NGO works with an FOP?
By the way, we provide services for NGOs: audit, financial accounting and bookkeeping, HR administration and payroll, as well as preparation of all types of reports, including tax reports. Please contact us here.
Who FOPs are under Ukrainian law
First, a short reminder of who FOPs are, which taxation systems they can use and what the main groups and the conditions for each group are.
Under Ukrainian law, FOP status is obtained through state registration. It allows an individual to carry out business activities at their own risk and to be liable for these activities with all their property. There are two taxation systems: the simplified system and the general system. Most FOPs register under the simplified taxation system if their income and other conditions allow it. It is simpler and more cost-effective for the FOPs themselves.
The simplified system has the following groups:
- Group 1: individuals; an income limit of 167 minimum wages, as set by law on January 1 of the tax (reporting) year; a monthly single tax rate of 10% of the subsistence minimum; no hired employees; activities: mainly retail trade at markets and household services to the public.
- Group 2: individuals; an income limit of 834 minimum wages, as set by law on January 1 of the tax (reporting) year; a monthly single tax rate of 20% of the minimum wage; no more than 10 hired employees; activities: restaurant business and services only to the public and to single tax payers; the option to sell goods to legal entities on the general taxation system (GTS).
- Group 3: individuals and legal entities; an income limit of 1,167 minimum wages as set by law on January 1 of the tax (reporting) year; a tax rate of 3% plus VAT or 5% of the income received; an unlimited number of hired employees; activities: all except certain categories (see clause 291.5 of the Tax Code of Ukraine (TCU)); the option to sell goods and provide services to legal entities on the (GTS).
- There is also Group 4, but it is mostly for agricultural activities.
As you can see, the main differences between the groups are the income limit (and, as a result, the tax rate) and whether the FOP can hire employees and carry out certain activities. Since 2023, there has also been a requirement to use an RRO (a cash register or payment terminal).
So, as we can see, NGOs can mainly engage FOPs of Group 3 and partly FOPs of Group 2 (for purchases of necessary goods). They can also engage FOPs on the general taxation system.
Can NGOs sign contracts with FOPs: benefits and risks
When one-off tasks arise, it is not always practical to hire the right professional on staff. An NGO can turn to self-employed persons or FOPs. The law does not directly prohibit working with FOPs, so NGOs can sign contracts with them.
The benefits of such relations include:
- there is no need to hire an employee on staff when an FOP performs the work (services); as a result, there is less HR work related to hiring, dismissal and leave
- a lower tax burden, because the NGO is not a tax agent for the FOP and does not have to pay taxes, as it would when paying a salary to an employee. The FOP pays their own taxes.
- the FOP is interested in being paid and completes the task as quickly as possible and with the best result for the client.
However, there are some warnings about engaging FOPs:
- The tax authorities may treat long-term work with an FOP with monthly payments of the same amount as hidden employment. This is especially likely if the FOP does the same work or provides the same services as an employee whose position is in the staffing table. If the relationship is recognized as employment, the tax authorities will assess additional payroll taxes in full. They will also impose penalties for unofficial employment. For example, the fine for allowing an employee to work without an employment contract is 10 minimum wages for each employee (UAH 67,000 in 2023), and 30 minimum wages for a repeated violation within two years. There is no limitation period for these fines, which means that the employer (owner) can be held liable at any time.
- As mentioned above, not all FOPs can provide services or goods to NGOs. In general, if an FOP of another group provides services to an NGO, the greater tax risks are for that FOP. However, we do not rule out that the tax authorities may try to accuse the NGO of failing to perform the duties of a tax agent when making such payments to the FOP, based on subparagraph 177.6 of the TCU. There have also been cases when government authorities declared such transactions invalid as a whole
because the FOP had not registered the relevant KVED code (Ukraine’s classification of economic activities) (see the rulings of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine of May 18, 2017 in case No. K/800/13843/16* and of September 27, 2016 No. K/800/12450/15).
- If the FOP is directly connected with the founders, participants, members of the governing bodies or other persons of the NGO, such payments may be treated as a distribution of profit. An NGO with non-profit status is prohibited from distributing its income (profits) among its founders, participants, members of the governing bodies and other persons related to the NGO (subparagraph 133.4.1 of paragraph 133.4 of Article 133 of the TCU). Related FOPs involved in the work may be included in this group.
So, in general, the law does not provide for direct sanctions for working with FOPs. The main thing is to comply with the conditions of the FOP’s group and with the requirements for the use of funds. Funds may be used to finance the NGO’s own maintenance within the approved limits for certain types of NGOs (we discussed this here) and to achieve the aims (goals, tasks) and areas of activity set out in the constituent documents (subparagraph 133.4.2 of paragraph 133.4 of Article 133 of the TCU). When working with FOPs, NGO managers should carefully consider all the advantages and disadvantages and make a balanced decision that takes all the details into account.
An NGO employee as an FOP
In practice, it is very common for an individual who is in fact an employee not to sign an employment contract with the NGO but to work with it as an FOP on a permanent basis. Above, we discussed this format of relations: it has its benefits, but there are also risks because of the position of government authorities.
There may be cases when an individual works for an NGO as an employee and also provides additional services as an FOP. An NGO can sign a contract for the necessary work or services with an employee who is registered as an FOP. However, the NGO must be careful when drawing up such a contract. The employee’s job duties must not coincide with the types of services or work that they provide as an FOP, and their work schedule and similar factors must be taken into account. These precautions follow from the definition of a “self-employed person” (subparagraph 14.1.226 of the TCU).
So, when signing a contract with an FOP, it is worth checking once again that the contract describes the service or goods themselves, not the process of providing or making them. The contract should also clearly set the price, the payment procedure, the deadlines, the option to sign addendums for new types of services or work, etc. (Articles 903 and 905 of the Civil Code of Ukraine). Our experts can assist you with this; you can find more information here.
Payments between NGOs and FOPs
Today, most current payments of companies, including NGOs, are cashless. They go through the modern banking system from any device that fits in your hand. With more liberal laws, opening an account takes about as long as reading this text, and some banks even let you open an account without leaving home.
However, not all businesses have this advantage. For example, the conditions for opening accounts for non-resident NGOs are somewhat different, and we will definitely cover this issue in our next articles.
So payments to an FOP are mostly made to the account opened for the FOP as a business, not for the individual (the account number must contain the digits UAxxxxxxxx..2600..). This is simpler than paying in cash, and there is no need to deal with an RRO. If an FOP still uses a personal account for business, this is, first, a violation. Second, the tax authorities may treat the NGO as a tax agent, and as a result the NGO will have to pay taxes as for transactions under civil-law contracts. Of course, all the necessary documents that confirm the work performed (services provided) must be drawn up: the contract and the delivery note/acceptance certificate.
Conclusions
To sum up, an NGO can work with FOPs and make payments to them. However, there are some details worth paying attention to when working with FOPs:
- before starting a business relationship, check the counterparty: whether its registration in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities, Individual Entrepreneurs and Public Organizations (Ukraine’s official business register) is up to date, its taxation system, its group and its KVED codes
- whether the services provided by the FOP match the NGO’s areas of activity set out in its constituent documents.
- the duties and work schedule set for an employee must not coincide with the obligations and conditions under the contract with the FOP (by types of services/work). However, donors may object to working with FOPs. If this has been agreed with the donor, the main thing is to draw up the contract with the FOP carefully.
In general, cooperation between NGOs and FOPs can have its own specifics and requires an individual approach to each case. That is why it is worth getting an individual tax consultation or advice from professionals in this field.
Links and abbreviations used in the text
- Tax Code of Ukraine
- Civil Code of Ukraine
- Labor Code of Ukraine
- NGO: a non-governmental organization, or a non-state organization, or NGO (Non-Governmental Organization), or a public organization, or a public union, or a charitable institution, or a charitable society, or a public association.
- FOP: a sole proprietor (fizychna osoba-pidpryiemets).
Nataliia Lytvynenko
Project Manager
Volodymyr Zhyvun
Expert




